LeBron James vs. Michael Jordan Debate Rages On as Bill Simmons Suggests Banning Obsessive Fans on Elon Musk’s X

The debate over who is the greatest basketball player of all time—LeBron James or Michael Jordan—has been one of the most talked-about topics in sports history. Social media, especially Elon Musk’s X, has turned this discussion into an endless cycle of hot takes, arguments, and heated debates. Fans on both sides spend hours crafting narratives, statistics, and comparisons to push their preferred GOAT.
Recently, NBA podcaster Bill Simmons and analyst Ryen Russillo weighed in on the issue in a humorous way, suggesting that users who dedicate half their posts to LeBron vs. Jordan should be banned from the platform. Their conversation also touched on Luka Doncic’s transition to the Lakers and how critics unfairly blamed James for the star guard’s early struggles.

During the latest episode of ‘The Bill Simmons Podcast’, Russillo proposed a drastic—albeit joking—solution to the endless GOAT debate: "If 50% of your tweets are on LeBron or Jordan, you should just be banned from the platform." Simmons, amused by the idea, played along, saying, "It's fair, we'll talk to Elon about it."

The discussion was sparked by the reactions to Luka Doncic’s slow start with the Los Angeles Lakers following his shocking midseason trade from the Dallas Mavericks. Some critics claimed that James’ ball dominance was holding Doncic back after he struggled in his first three games. However, Simmons and Russillo pushed back against those claims, explaining that Doncic’s early struggles were more about his conditioning and the mental adjustment of leaving Dallas—a team he had envisioned playing for long-term.

LeBron James’ impact on the Lakers remains undeniable, but he still faces relentless criticism—especially from Michael Jordan supporters. Addressing this ongoing scrutiny, Lakers guard Austin Reaves told ESPN, "He really doesn't have anything else to prove. And if people say he does, then they're [Michael] Jordan fans."

James continues to prove his doubters wrong, even in his 22nd NBA season. In a recent game against the Portland Trail Blazers, the 40-year-old put on a scoring clinic, dropping 40 points on the second night of a back-to-back, leading the Lakers to a hard-fought 110-102 victory. His ability to dominate at this stage of his career further cements his case as one of the all-time greats.
Despite playing in different eras with different styles, the LeBron James vs. Michael Jordan debate continues to rage on. With James still adding to his legacy, his supporters argue that his longevity and all-around game make him the greatest. Meanwhile, Jordan’s fans hold firm that his six championships and perfect Finals record set him apart.
Also Read: Luka Doncic and LeBron James Lead Los Angeles Lakers to Victory Over Denver Nuggets, Jamal Murray Reacts to Losing Streak Break
While Simmons and Russillo’s comments about banning X users were clearly tongue-in-cheek, they highlight the obsession surrounding this debate. As long as James is still playing at a high level, and social media remains a battleground for sports arguments, the GOAT conversation isn’t going away anytime soon.