GTG - Malta Law Firm reposted this
The Less is More Report is timely & it exposes the unchecked regulatory inflation within the EU financial sector, highlighting how European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) are eroding institutional balance by expanding their mandates beyond legal bounds. I would like to express a serious concern tied with the above. The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) in particular seems intent to be the next European Banking Authority (EBA), expanding its powers despite clear legal limits particularly under MiCAR. Its overreach isn’t new. The European Commission has already reprimanded it for outsourcing standards under DORA. The report confirms this dangerous shift. By positioning itself as the de facto enforcer of broad crypto-asset oversight, European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) is effectively attempting to shape policy rather than merely enforce it. This overreach aligns with concerns raised in the Less is More report, which identifies the shifting of normative power away from EU co-legislators towards ESAs and highlights the institutional imbalance this creates. The Commission’s rebuke under DORA should have served as a warning, yet ESMA appears undeterred. Rather than exercising caution and respecting the carefully crafted division of regulatory powers, it continues to seek opportunities to embed itself deeper into areas where its legal competence is, at best, ambiguous. The result is a creeping regulatory encroachment that risks undermining the legal certainty necessary for stable financial markets. The broader concern here is the erosion of the EU’s institutional balance. The Less is More report identifies multiple instances where ESAs have overstepped their mandates, raising serious concerns about democratic oversight and institutional accountability. The report strongly advocates for strengthening political control over ESAs and limiting the scope of their soft law interventions & provides a comprehensive set of recommendations to curb this trend, including reforms to the governance of ESAs, enhanced judicial review mechanisms, and stricter adherence to the principles of proportionality and legal certainty. It also confirms that ESAs are increasingly bypassing co-legislators, undermining legal certainty. Regulators must enforce, not legislate. Institute of Financial Services Practitioners FIMA Financial Institutions Malta Association Malta Financial Services Authority (MFSA) GTG - Malta Law Firm Jonathan Galea #ESMA #Regulation #MiCAR #DORA #Fintech #FinancialMarkets #EUlaw #Compliance #RegulatoryOverreach #InstitutionalBalance