Containers versus VMs (virtual machines)

Containers and virtual machines (VMs) are two foundational technologies that enable applications to run in isolated environments. While both offer benefits like resource management and portability, they differ significantly in their architecture, resource utilization, and use cases. Choosing the right technology depends on your specific application requirements and business goals. Let's explore the key differences between containers and VMs to help you make an informed decision.

Learn about VMs versus containers

What are containers?

Containers are lightweight, portable, and self-contained executable images that contain software applications and their dependencies. They are used to deploy and run applications in a consistent way across different environments, such as development, staging, and production. Containers are typically deployed from an image by using an orchestration platform, like Kubernetes. These platforms provide a way to manage and deploy containers at scale.

Containers have a number of benefits over traditional virtualization methods. As they are more lightweight and portable than VMs, containers support decomposition of a monolith into microservices. Containers are faster to manage and deploy than VMs, which can save time and money with application deployment.

What are virtual machines?

Virtual machines (VMs) or guests represent instances of an operating system co-located on a physical machine through the use of a hypervisor. Each VM has its own operating system, memory, and other resources, which are isolated from the other VMs on the same physical computer. This allows multiple operating systems to run on the same physical components without interfering with each other.

Virtual machines are created and managed using hypervisor software. A hypervisor is software that manages a physical computer's resources and allocates them to virtual machines.

Difference between containers and VMs

Virtual machines access the hardware of a physical machine through a hypervisor. The hypervisor creates an abstraction layer allowing the VM to access CPU, memory, and storage. Containers, on the other hand, represent a package that includes an executable with the dependencies it needs to run.

This means that each container shares the physical machine's hardware and operating system kernel with other containers.

As a result, virtual machines are typically more resource-intensive than containers. However, virtual machines also provide a high level of isolation, which can be important for security and compliance reasons. Containers are more lightweight and portable than virtual machines. This makes them a good choice for applications that need to be deployed quickly and easily, where compute must be optimized.

See the comparison chart to further understand the differences between containers and virtual machines:

Feature

Container

Virtual machine


Virtualization level


Operating system Level

Hardware level

Operating system


Shares host OS kernel

Guest OS (full OS instance)


Size

Megabytes (MBs)

Gigabytes (GBs)

Boot time


Seconds


Minutes


Resource usage

Lower


Higher


Isolation


Process-level

Hardware-level


Portability

Highly portable


Less portable


Management


Typically managed by container orchestration tools (for example Kubernetes)

Managed by hypervisors (e.g., VMware, KVM) or cloud management platforms

Use cases

Microservices, web applications, CI/CD pipelines, cloud-native applications

Legacy applications, applications requiring strong isolation, diverse OS requirements

Feature

Container

Virtual machine


Virtualization level


Operating system Level

Hardware level

Operating system


Shares host OS kernel

Guest OS (full OS instance)


Size

Megabytes (MBs)

Gigabytes (GBs)

Boot time


Seconds


Minutes


Resource usage

Lower


Higher


Isolation


Process-level

Hardware-level


Portability

Highly portable


Less portable


Management


Typically managed by container orchestration tools (for example Kubernetes)

Managed by hypervisors (e.g., VMware, KVM) or cloud management platforms

Use cases

Microservices, web applications, CI/CD pipelines, cloud-native applications

Legacy applications, applications requiring strong isolation, diverse OS requirements

Solve your business challenges with Google Cloud

New customers get $300 in free credits to spend on Google Cloud.
Talk to a Google Cloud sales specialist to discuss your unique challenge in more detail.

Architecture of containers versus virtual machines

To understand the differences between containers and VMs, it's helpful to visualize their architecture:

  • Containers:
  • Share the host OS kernel: Containers leverage the underlying operating system kernel of the host machine.
  • Lightweight: Smaller in size and require fewer resources compared to VMs.
  • Faster startup: Start and stop quickly due to shared OS kernel.
  • Virtual machines:
  • Run a full guest OS: Each VM has its own dedicated operating system, isolated from other VMs.
  • Resource-intensive: Require more resources (CPU, memory, storage) compared to containers.
  • Slower startup: Take longer to boot up due to the need to load the guest OS.

Similarities between containers and virtual machines

While containers and virtual machines serve different purposes, they are not mutually exclusive. In fact, they can often be used together to create a powerful and flexible infrastructure.

  • Containers are segregated applications or services on a host and share the same operating system
  • Virtual machines are isolated instances of an operating system on a physical host and run applications or services

Containers have a smaller footprint than virtual machines. This is because containers share the host operating system's kernel, while virtual machines each have their own kernel. As a result, containers can start and stop faster, and they use fewer resources.Virtual machines are isolated from each other, which can help to prevent attacks from spreading between guests.

Containers and VMs

Here are some common ways containers and virtual machines can be used together:

Running containers inside VMs can provide an extra layer of isolation and security. This approach is often used in environments where security is paramount, such as financial services or healthcare.

  • Example: A bank runs its containerized applications within VMs to comply with strict regulatory requirements.


Deploying Kubernetes clusters on VMs provides a flexible and scalable infrastructure for managing containerized applications. This allows you to leverage the benefits of both technologies.

  • Example: A large enterprise uses Google Compute Engine VMs to host its Kubernetes clusters, providing a scalable and resilient platform for its containerized workloads.


Using both containers and VMs in a hybrid cloud environment allows you to run applications on-premises and in the cloud, depending on your specific needs.

  • Example: A retail company uses VMs to run its core business applications on-premises, while using containers to deploy new, cloud-native applications in Google Cloud.


Use cases for containers

Containers are a popular choice for a variety of use cases, including:

  • Web development: Containers are a good choice for web development because they can be easily deployed to a variety of environments, such as development, staging, and production
  • Microservices architecture: Containers are a good choice for microservices architecture because they can be used to deploy and manage individual services
  • Cloud computing: Containers are a good choice for cloud computing because they can be easily scaled up or down to meet demand
  • Continuous integration and delivery (CI/CD): Containers can be used to support automated processes of building, testing, and deploying applications

Containers are a powerful tool that can be used to improve application development, deployment, and management. They are a good choice for a variety of use cases, and are becoming increasingly popular in the cloud computing industry.

Use cases for virtual machines

Virtual machines are a popular choice for a variety of use cases, including:

  • Testing: Virtual machines can be used to test new software in a safely sandboxed environment. This is because the VM can be easily reset or deleted if the software causes problems.
  • Development: Virtual machines can be used to develop software on different operating systems. This can be useful for developers who need to test their software on different operating systems, or for users who want to use different operating systems for different tasks.
  • Isolation: Virtual machines can be used to isolate applications from each other. This can be useful for security segmentation and resource partitioning.
  • Cloud computing: Virtual machines are a popular choice for cloud computing because they can be easily scaled up or down to meet demand.
  • Disaster recovery: Virtual machines can be used in support of disaster recovery strategies. This is because the VM can be easily restored from a backup if the host machine fails.

Virtual machines are powerful tools that can be used for various purposes. They are a cost-effective way to run multiple operating systems and applications on the same computer, and they can be used to test new software in a safe environment.

When to use containers versus virtual machines

The choice between containers and virtual machines depends on your specific requirements. Here's a guide:

Use Case

Recommendation

Enterprise business example

Microservices applications

Containers


An ecommerce company uses containers to deploy its microservices-based platform, enabling independent scaling and faster development cycles.

Legacy application modernization

Containers


A financial institution containerizes its legacy applications to migrate them to the cloud, improving portability and reducing infrastructure costs.


Continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD)

Containers

A software company uses containers to create consistent and reproducible CI/CD pipelines, ensuring reliable deployments across different environments.


Security-sensitive applications


Virtual machines


A healthcare provider uses virtual machines to isolate sensitive patient data, meeting strict compliance requirements.


Running different operating systems


Virtual machines

A software developer uses virtual machines to test applications on different operating systems (Windows, Linux, macOS) simultaneously.

Resource-intensive workloads


Virtual machines

A media company uses virtual machines to run video encoding and transcoding workloads, taking advantage of dedicated CPU and memory resources.

Use Case

Recommendation

Enterprise business example

Microservices applications

Containers


An ecommerce company uses containers to deploy its microservices-based platform, enabling independent scaling and faster development cycles.

Legacy application modernization

Containers


A financial institution containerizes its legacy applications to migrate them to the cloud, improving portability and reducing infrastructure costs.


Continuous integration/continuous delivery (CI/CD)

Containers

A software company uses containers to create consistent and reproducible CI/CD pipelines, ensuring reliable deployments across different environments.


Security-sensitive applications


Virtual machines


A healthcare provider uses virtual machines to isolate sensitive patient data, meeting strict compliance requirements.


Running different operating systems


Virtual machines

A software developer uses virtual machines to test applications on different operating systems (Windows, Linux, macOS) simultaneously.

Resource-intensive workloads


Virtual machines

A media company uses virtual machines to run video encoding and transcoding workloads, taking advantage of dedicated CPU and memory resources.

Take the next step

Start building on Google Cloud with $300 in free credits and 20+ always free products.

Google Cloud