By this point you’re likely as bored as I with all the veiled references to the COVID pandemic bubbling throughout the media. It’s become a deeply unhelpful prism with which we will ever have to view our experience of 2020. A lingering, disconsolate pain tied to each and every song heard, and text read. I’m hardly one to talk, much of this year’s blog has been fuelled by that same numbing “well what else is there to do?” question that confronts me daily. These words will never exist separate from their Corona context, just as media published between mid-November and late-December will never exist separate from Christmas. Oh yeah, that’s a festive segue if ever I saw one! Christmas is upon us once again as somehow, despite life having been suspended since March, this weird year has flown by. It’s taken me by surprise, if I’m honest, I’m mentally still in mid-August. So as this is a music blog, tradition dictates that I pluck one of the legions of Christmas songs and offer some thoughts. It’s what you expect, and given the year we’ve had, it’s the least I could offer. But I dunno, don’t you want a change? I know I do, desperately. I’m so tired of the mundane and expected. So frustrated at the lazy, inarticulate dumbing down of our cultural actions and so annoyed at content culture in general. Yet, my business hat, the one that is overly concerned with SEO and marketing, always tells me that by writing about one of the greatest Christmas songs will tap into the festive zeitgeist in a way that can only be beneficial for my future economic standing. It whispers the promise of click rates and conversion percentages if only I produce 700 words on Donny Hathaway’s soul epic ‘This Christmas’. I mean, as far as songs go, ‘This Christmas’ is one of the greats regardless of the season, but I’m reticent. Giving people what they want (or more specifically, what you tell them they want) kinda got us into this mess of a year. The people wanted to burn the international order and destroy their livelihoods in the process. The people wanted the freedom to infect their nearest and dearest without consequence. The people, as presented by the media-savvy, are wrong in the head, frankly. On the other hand, the community, those that you engage with on a regular basis, can be daaaaamn smart if our trust lets them. My community is you guys, so I trust you’ll forgive me for wanting to buck the system a little. Donny Hathaway wrote a masterpiece that eclipses ‘This Christmas’, and I want to talk about it.
‘I Love the Lord, He Heard My Cry (Pts. I & II)’ is not what you’d expect from a soul artist, regardless of whether you knew Hathaway’s instrumental upbringing or not. Soul conjures images of rhythm sections locked in a groove as keys and a tight horn section offer their passionate replies to a silky vocal. So, goes much of what we would consider Soul, and so goes much of Hathaway’s incredible output. Why mess with the formula? Just give people what they want, right? Nope. Whether by accident or design, Hathaway chose to begin his final album, Extension of a Man (1973), with the piece in question and, I mean, wow! This is a work that condenses all the joy and strength of belief inherent in soul music into a 5-minute Classical odyssey. The tight sax section replaced with sforzando brass, the bass guitar replaced with contrabassoon and pizzicato strings, the voice replaced entirely by lilting ostinatos in the winds. I first heard this a few days ago after my Spotify did one of its annoying auto-plays into the “insert-artist-you-were-just-listening-to” radio, moments after I’d reacquainted myself with Hathaway’s debut, Everything is Everything (1970). I genuinely thought that the algorithm had finally broken, collapsing into obscurity and heralding the final death of technological mediation. It was a wild second, that. One of the year’s highlights for sure. But I checked my phone only to find that this heir to the Appalachian classical tradition, nudged into life by the great Aaron Copland, was the very same soulful genius I’d spent the previous 45 grooving to. That’s where I placed it, next to Copland and next to Gershwin (who, admittedly, Hathaway references). That’s where this work could easily belong, amongst the classical pantheon. But it’s not, it exists at the head of an incredible album, living with each and every rotation of the vinyl.

That’s not to say classical music doesn’t live when listened to, of course it does! But the fact remains that you likely knew who Donny Hathaway was but had to look up Aaron Copland. When it comes to raw numbers, Pop wins hands down, and therein lies the true wonder of ‘I Love the Lord, He Heard My Cry (Pts. I & II)’. This piece, with its deeply classical, Hathaway penned arrangement, would have been heard by a soul audience likely unaccustomed to the form. This makes Hathaway one of those incredibly rare cultural gatekeepers who actually use their skills and knowledge for communal good instead of the people’s greed. He didn’t use the form in order to widen his market share or appeal to a new demographic, but to instead offer something fresh and fulfilling to his community. Likewise he specifically chose, through it’s placement in the track listing, to delay giving the people what they want in order to make an artistic point. He trusted his audience, his community, to understand this music, despite it’s sonic irregularities. But all this is secondary to the fact that in this music Hathaway built a world that shocked me, musical misanthrope such as I am, in its beauty. I always thought I was pretty dang good at arranging, now I realise I know nothing and I love it! See, this piece came to me right at the end of this odd period, at a time when I normally tot up the year behind and build the energy required to forge forward into the one ahead. This year, dampened this energy somewhat, as it has for all of us. But I dunno, I’m starting to feel it again. Deep in my bones. That tingle of excitement and belief that next year could be good, it could be very good. Who knows? Life is there for the taking if we just trust in ourselves and look out for our own communities. This a feeling that no number of epic Christmas songs could have ever wrought from me. This required something special.
Thank you, Donny.
—
I’ve been writing this blog on and off for a while now, so why not dip back into the halcyon years by having a read of these related posts:
Judge not, lest ye be judged. If you feel the urge to subjectively critique my own musical work you can find it by clicking here.








