Jozef Czapski is an author whose books have made a couple of appearances on the blog previously. Back in 2019, I wrote about “Lost Time“, a collection of lectures he gave on Proust whilst incarcerated in a Soviet concentration camp; and in 2022 I shared my thoughts on his “Memories of Starobielsk“, covering his time in that camp. Both titles were issued by NYRB Classics, and they’ve also published two other titles by and about him: a biography by Eric Karpeles, and a book I’m covering today: “Inhuman Land: Searching for the Truth in Soviet Russia, 1941–1942” (translated by Antonia Lloyd-Jones). It’s a powerful and sobering read, and one which resonates in our fractured modern world.

As I’ve mentioned before, Josef Czapski was a remarkable man. A polymath, his life took in painting, writing and essays as well as military and diplomatic careers. Czapski lived through the bulk of the 20th century; born in Poland in 1896, he was a student in St. Petersburg during the Russian Revolution, a painter in Paris mingling with the likes of Picasso, and during the Second World War fought as an office in the Polish army. Somehow, miraculously, he and a group of less than four hundred men survived the Soviet murder of more than 20,000 Polish officers (the Katyn Massacre); instead, they were incarcerated in a Soviet prison camp 250 miles north of Moscow. “Inhuman Land” tells the story of his time after release from the camp, and his search for the truth about those missing officers; it reveals much about a pivotal time during WW2.
Poland fought in the war with the Allies against Nazi Germany; at this point, the Soviet Union was neutral with a non-aggression pact agreed between themselves and Hitler. Bordering the Soviet Union, Poland was vulnerable and when invaded by Germany and Russia, the country was partitioned up between them. However, when sides switched in 1941, as Germany invaded the Soviet Union, suddenly Poland was freed to form an army to fight alongside Allied troops. That’s a very simplified version of a complex situation, but it meant that officers like Czapski were released from camps and set off to form those armies. That in itself was a difficult and traumatic task, as the conditions were horrific, there was a shortage of all basic necessities such as food, clothing, medicines and weapons, and many of the Polish people were ill or dying.
Czapski’s narrative reveals the horrors of the situation; but he had an initial mission and that was to try to track down the missing Polish officers who had disappeared from the camps. At the time, it was not know that they had been massacred, and so he travels from place to place, including a visit to Moscow, to try to get to the bottom of things. Everywhere he meets evasions, delaying tactics and lies; and eventually it becomes clear that he’ll never be able to get any answers from the Soviet authorities. His accounts of what it’s like to try to negotiate Soviet bureaucracy are chilling.
Nobody could possibly understand it—it would take a brilliant writer, a superb observer, a new Tolstoy or Proust, Russian or Polish, to describe the atmosphere that prevailed in Russia, at every moment, and the things that would suddenly give the game away in the course of ordinary, everyday life—a small gesture or a memorable glance. It wasn’t the difficult conditions or the hunger—all that was less awful than the suppression of humanity, the mute look in the eyes of people among whom just about everybody had lost at least one of their closest relatives to the camps in the north.
So Czapski travels south with his fellow survivors, providing education and support where he can, witnessing and recording his compatriots’ sufferings, and all the while trying to retain his humanity. The would-be army crossed Soviet Asia into Iran, Iraq and Palestine before eventually fighting in the pivotal battle at Monte Cassino. All the while, Poland and its people hoped the west would stand by them after the war and ensure they retained their country; however, it’s very clear that the Allies totally abandoned Poland and the country was one of many which suffered from the ever-shifting European borders of the 20th century.
“Inhuman Land” is a remarkable book on many levels. Firstly, as I’ve seen before, Czapski writes so well (and here the translation is elegantly done by the esteemed Antonia Lloyd-Jones). The subject matter is dark and harsh – Czapski does not shy away from relating the horrors of war, the casual brutality and the mass killings – and yet there are parts of the book which reflect a lyrical beauty. The author’s artist’s eye records the changing landscape around him, the differing countries through which he travels, and the people he encounters on the way. There is a touching meeting with the poet Anna Akhmatova in exile which will stay with me. Czapski notes the fact that, as ever, the powerful never suffer the privations of the ordinary people; and at some points in the narrative it’s hard not to think the human race is a hideous one and that the world might be better off without it…
The book comes in two parts; the first section, covering the search for the truth about the officers, and the journey south as part of the army, was originally published soon after the war; later additions were made. Part two was written some 20 years later and allows Czapski to look back at his experiences within the Polish army, as well as a final chapter in which the author allows himself to contemplate Germany and the German people. This is particularly interesting, as when he was writing the war was still very recent, and Czapski finds that the German people he encounters are already turning their back on history. He contemplates how humans can behave with brutality towards one group of people, yet with tenderness towards their own kind; it’s a question that’s still very relevant today and I don’t believe it’s ever been answered.
Centuries go by, regimes change, but people remain, just the same, despite the spread of education and propaganda.
I started reading “Inhuman Land” alongside “Ulysses” at the end of May, but soon put it aside to read on its own once I had finished Joyce. It’s a deeply absorbing book; often hard to read, stark and troubling, and you have to brace yourself at times. The fate of ordinary people, children and prisoners who’ve been through the camp system is devastating; and books like this do bear importance witness of the many horrors of 20th century conflict. Alas, as I’ve hinted, I don’t know that humanity is doing any better in the 21st century; but it’s important that we don’t forget. It’s taken a while for me to get to this book (which was released in 2019), but it’s an important and powerful read which will definitely stay with me.
(Review copy kindly provided by NYRB Classics, for which many thanks).
